top of page
photo-1610733254972-c72d9987d188.jpg
BLOGS

Buying a Historic Building on Miner Street in Idaho Springs: What Needs City Approval

6 days ago
5 min read
Small-town main street with cars, storefronts and pedestrians under cloudy sky; signs include One Way and West Winds Tavern.
Miner Street in Idaho Springs. Photo: Kent Kanouse

Miner Street's brick storefronts date mainly from the late 1800s through the early 1900s, and owning one comes with a partner: the City's Historic Preservation Review Commission. Exterior changes to properties in the Historic District can require historic review and a Certificate of Appropriateness before a building permit can be issued. Knowing that before you buy tells you what the building can become and how much time to allow for the process.


How review works


  • The district. The City's Historic Preservation Design Guidelines describe the Miner Street Commercial District as a collection of one- and two-story brick buildings, along with a few frame buildings. The core brick commercial buildings were constructed between 1877 and 1920. The district remains a functioning commercial area rather than simply a preserved streetscape.

  • Who decides. The Historic Preservation Review Commission reviews building and sign applications for properties within the Historic District or otherwise designated for preservation. The City currently lists HPRC meetings for the third Tuesday of each month at 6 p.m., as needed.

  • What triggers review. The City's current COA procedure says applications for building permits within the Historic District—or at designated historic sites—that involve a new structure, an external modification to an existing structure, or demolition must first go to the HPRC for a Certificate of Appropriateness. The City's design guidelines state that affected property owners making exterior changes must receive a COA before securing a building permit.

  • Timing. Don't build a renovation schedule around a simple five-day review. The City's current COA checklist gives the City Planner up to 14 days to review application materials before the project moves toward the next available HPRC meeting. A public notice sign is also required 15 days before the scheduled meeting. For a major renovation, build real time into the schedule for review, comments, revisions, and resubmittal if needed.

  • Smaller jobs. Not every repair means a full HPRC hearing. The City's guidelines distinguish routine maintenance and repair from work that changes the exterior appearance or significant historic materials, and the City provides a process for smaller projects that may be handled administratively. If you're unsure, ask the City Planner before assuming a project is exempt.


What the guidelines say about the changes owners usually want


The City's current guidelines get specific about the details that make these buildings look like Idaho Springs rather than a generic new commercial project.


  • Windows: The guidelines identify vinyl-clad and aluminum windows as inappropriate in historic applications and discourage large areas of glass on upper floors and the sides of commercial buildings.

  • Storefronts: The design should maintain a clear distinction between the street-level storefront and upper floors. Where an entry is recessed, the upper floors should maintain the established building line.

  • Signs and awnings: Signs should relate to the horizontal lines of existing storefront elements such as moldings and transoms. Awnings should fit the storefront or window opening rather than overwhelm it.

  • Masonry: Replacement mortar should be compatible with the original masonry in strength, composition, and color. That's particularly important on older brick buildings.

  • Paint: The guidelines don't prescribe a single paint color, but they point owners toward historically appropriate color schemes.

  • Mechanical and rooftop equipment: The guidelines address the placement and screening of mechanical equipment and other rooftop or exterior elements so they don't overwhelm the historic character of the building.


The practical takeaway is simple: don't buy the building first and figure out the exterior later. If your business plan depends on a new storefront, large windows, rooftop equipment, signage, an addition, or a major exterior renovation, talk with the City before you make assumptions about what will be approved.


Before you close, have a structural engineer and an inspector familiar with historic masonry look at the building. Our local network includes inspectors and engineers who work Clear Creek County.


Historic tax credits can help offset the cost


Colorado's Commercial Historic Preservation Tax Credit can be significant for the right project, but the rules are more specific than simply being an old building.


Under the current OEDIT program, qualifying commercial properties generally need to produce income, be at least 30 years old, and be listed on the State Register of Historic Properties or landmarked by a certified local government. The rehabilitation also has to meet the program's substantial-rehabilitation and preservation requirements.


For commercial projects, the current base credit is:


  • 25% of qualified rehabilitation expenses up to $2 million

  • 20% of qualified expenses above $2 million

  • 35% for qualifying projects in rural areas on expenses up to $2 million

  • 30% for qualifying rural projects on expenses above $2 million


The maximum credit for a large or small commercial project is generally $1 million per property per year. The credit is transferable, subject to the program's requirements.


The current OEDIT program page says the small project pool is accepting waitlist applications, while the large project pool has reached its statutory limit and is scheduled to reopen January 19, 2027. Because credits can be allocated quickly, the state recommends planning ahead rather than assuming funding will be available when construction starts.


There is also a federal historic rehabilitation tax credit for qualifying income-producing historic buildings, administered through the National Park Service and federal tax rules. Have your CPA or tax advisor confirm whether the specific property and rehabilitation qualify before you build the credit into your investment model.


The important point for a buyer is that the tax credit should be part of the due-diligence conversation before the renovation is designed—not an assumption made after the work is finished.


Traffic and tenants


Miner Street runs alongside the I-70 corridor, and Idaho Springs also serves travelers heading toward the Mount Blue Sky area. The City's own historic guidelines note that the commercial district continues to serve miners, skiers, hunters, campers, tourists, travelers, and local residents.


For a commercial buyer, pull actual traffic information from CDOT's traffic-count data rather than relying on a number in a listing.


On the ground floor, restaurants, brewpubs, coffee shops, and visitor-oriented retail can make sense depending on the building, lease economics, parking, access, and permitted use. Upper floors can have different possibilities depending on zoning and the property's specific approvals.

And if your business plan involves a restaurant, don't leave the exterior review until the end. Kitchen exhaust, rooftop equipment, penetrations, signage, and other exterior changes can become part of the historic-review conversation.


Our commercial page covers how we approach building ownership across our five counties.


If you'd like to go over a particular Miner Street building and what the City's review process could mean for your plans, set up a time with an advisor. We're happy to look at the building from both the real-estate and practical ownership side.


This article was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence and reviewed for accuracy before publication. Historic review requirements, tax-credit availability, and permitting rules can change. Confirm requirements for a specific property and project with the City of Idaho Springs, the appropriate preservation authorities, and your tax advisor.


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
WSJ
Summit Realtors
global marketing agency
Certified real estate expert
Crexi
The Summit Chamber
Realtor
WA Logo (5)
Land Commercial
eXp Realty
Logo
login-logo
Farms USA
Core Logic
Logo
Logo
Logo
Logo
Land Watch
sd-logo-2
HuntStand
HP
AC _ Trademarked Logo_
Land Gate
Logo
Land Flip
LandHub
Recolorado_Logo

O F F I C E A D D R E S S

​

605 South Park Avenue, Breckenridge, CO 80424

​

Opening Hours  
Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM 

​

C O N T A C T

​

E: realestate@westwardbroker.com

P: 970 - 453 - 5700

T: 303 - 641 - 3341
 

Q U I C K  L I N K S​

​

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL

​

www.westwardbroker.com

Lindsey Stapay - Founder and Broker

Book a consultation

Licensed in Colorado

605 South Park Avenue, Breckenridge, CO 80424

 

Westward Broker is committed to providing an accessible website. If you have difficulty accessing content, have difficulty viewing a file on the website, or notice any accessibility problems, please contact us at 970.453.5700 to specify the nature of the accessibility issue and any assistive technology you use.

​

We strive to provide the content you need in the format you require.

​

Westward Broker 2026

All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page